top of page

Not everyone needs to talk it through straight away

Nov 3
3 min read

It's twenty past eleven on a Wednesday morning, and a teacher is sitting in the small meeting room off the front office with a cup of tea she hasn't touched. Half an hour ago, a Year 8 student she has worked hard with pushed past her so roughly on his way out of the room that she hit the doorframe. Someone kind has already covered her class. Someone else, just as kind, sits down across from her and says, "Tell me what happened, right from the start." She does, because that seems to be what's expected, and by the time she finishes she feels more shaken than when she sat down.


We're in Week 5 of Term 4, and hard incidents haven't slowed down just because the end of the year is in sight. In many schools there's a strong belief that the right response is to get people talking it through straight away, ideally in a structured debrief. That belief comes from real care, and talking can help. But it's worth testing gently, because the research points somewhere a little different, and the difference matters for how we look after each other in those first hours.


Where the idea came from


In the 1980s and 1990s, single-session "psychological debriefing" became common after distressing events, first in emergency services and then in hospitals and workplaces. The idea was simple and appealing. Soon after the event, people would go through what happened in detail, share how they felt, and hear that their reactions were normal. It made sense, and for a long time very few people checked whether it actually helped.


What the research found


A Cochrane review led by Suzanna Rose, with Jonathan Bisson, Rachel Churchill and Simon Wessely, first published in 2002 and later updated, looked at 15 randomised trials of single-session debriefing for people who had been through a traumatic event in the previous month. Debriefing didn't prevent post-traumatic stress or reduce distress compared with people who weren't debriefed. In one trial, the people who had been debriefed were more likely to have post-traumatic stress a year later. The authors concluded that compulsory debriefing should stop.


The limits are important. Many of the trials were of poor quality, and most involved car accidents, burns and assaults rather than schools. They tested one formal kind of session, not a colleague checking in, and not an operational review of what went wrong and what will change, which is a different and useful thing. None of this means talking is harmful. It suggests that pressing people to retell an event in detail, on a timetable that isn't theirs, isn't the help we assumed it was.


What to offer instead: look, listen, link


The World Health Organization's Psychological First Aid guide was written for the hours and days after a crisis. It is built around three plain actions, and it is clear that people shouldn't be pressured to tell their story. In a school, it might look like this.


  1. Look. Check safety and basic needs first. Is she hurt? Does she need first aid, water, a quiet room, someone to cover her class, or a call home?

  2. Listen. Offer to listen, and let her decide how much to say. "You don't have to go through it now. I'm here if you want to." Take a no at face value.

  3. Link. Connect her with practical help: who is contacting the family, who will help with the incident report, how to reach the employee assistance program, and when someone will check in tomorrow.


For leaders


Where you can, keep the operational review separate from personal support, and hold it a day or two later. Try to make sure the person doesn't have to retell the event to five different people, from the deputy to the principal to the support team. One trusted person can hold the story and pass on what others need to know.


What this can't do


A kinder first hour won't reduce how often incidents happen, and it can't replace proper behaviour support, staffing, or the employer's duty under Queensland's psychosocial hazards code to manage these risks. Support after an incident belongs to the system, not only to whichever colleague happens to be nearby. Within that, though, the way we sit with someone matters. Sometimes the most helpful thing is a fresh cup of tea, a covered class and a quiet "whenever you're ready", and if you're the one sitting with the cold tea, it's completely fine to say you'd rather not talk yet.



bottom of page