top of page

Can your staff tell you it isn't working?

5 days ago
3 min read

At 7:40 on a Thursday morning, a principal opens the results of the Term 4 staff pulse survey at her desk. They're mostly reassuring. Workload is rated as high but manageable, and most staff agree they feel supported. Two weeks earlier, though, two experienced teachers told her quietly that they won't be back next year, and a third has asked about part-time. None of what they told her in those conversations shows up in the survey.


We're in Week 6 of Term 4, when many leadership teams are deciding staffing, timetables and priorities for 2027. It's the time of year when it matters most to know what is really happening in classrooms and corridors, and often the time when staff are least likely to say so. This piece isn't about how much leaders carry, which is a real issue of its own. It's about a quieter question: whether the people around you can tell you that something isn't working.


The units with the most mistakes


In the early 1990s, Amy Edmondson, then a doctoral student at Harvard, was studying medication errors in hospital units. She expected the units with the strongest teamwork and leadership to make fewer errors. The data showed the opposite. The better-led units were reporting more errors, not fewer. When she looked closer, the likely explanation was that people in those units weren't making more mistakes. They felt safe enough to say when something had gone wrong, while staff in other units kept quiet.


She tested the idea more directly in a 1999 study of 51 work teams in a large manufacturing company. Teams who agreed that it was safe to take interpersonal risks, such as admitting a mistake, asking for help or raising a concern, were more likely to talk about problems, seek feedback and change how they worked. She called this shared belief psychological safety, and it was linked to better team performance.


The limits are worth naming. The hospital study involved only eight units, and the factory study was one company in the United States in the 1990s, measured at a single point in time. Neither was in a school, and neither proves cause and effect. Since then, though, the same pattern has been found in many workplaces, and it fits what a lot of school leaders already sense. A quiet staffroom isn't always a settled one.


How a leader responds to bad news


Psychological safety is built less by what a leader says in a staff meeting and more by what happens in the minute after someone brings a problem. A short routine can help make that minute consistent.


  1. Thank them first. Before anything else, say that you're glad they told you. It's easier to keep raising issues when the first response isn't defensive.

  2. Ask one specific question. Broad questions often get polite answers. "What's making the new behaviour process harder to use in your room?" tends to get a more useful reply than "How's it going?"

  3. Say what happens next, and when. Even if the answer is "I can't change the timetable this term, but I'll raise it at Tuesday's planning meeting," people need to know their concern went somewhere.

  4. Close the loop. Go back to them with what changed, or why it couldn't. This step is the one most often missed, and it's what shows people that speaking up was worth it.


For staff


If you're the one with the concern, it can help to bring it as something specific you've noticed, along with what you think would help, even if it's only a first idea. That isn't because the responsibility sits with you. It simply gives a busy leader something concrete to act on.


What this can't do


Psychological safety won't create more relief staff, smaller classes or extra hours in the day. Staff shouldn't have to be brave to raise a workload or safety problem, and listening well doesn't replace fixing what you hear. What it can do is make sure that the decisions being made for 2027 are based on what's really happening, rather than on a survey that looks fine. Sometimes the most useful thing a leader can do this month is ask one good question, thank the person who answers it honestly, and let them see what happens next.


Katherine

bottom of page